I have a dilemma. And I know it will be one that people have differing opinions on. But I’m trying to figure out how I feel about it, precisely.
You (maybe) know how on your Facebook timeline, you can scroll all the way back to “born 1983,” and you have blank years between, say, 1983 and 2006, when you actually set up your account. But at some point in the not-so-distant future, there is going to be a wave of teenagers with every single year of their lives filled out, thanks to their overenthusiastic parents.
And I guess no one really knows what this is going to mean for the future. And maybe I’m giving Facebook (or whatever comes after Facebook) too much credit. But I think it’s a pretty safe guess that things aren’t going to start turning backward. Everything’s going online.
When Drew and I got married, we got into a small scuffle or two with friends over the fact that we preferred that people not post tons of pictures of the wedding, particularly if they’re, you know, sitting in the back and taking pictures on their phone. Ultimately, yes, some pictures got posted, and it didn’t really bother either of us. But the other day, I saw that a (far-flung) friend of mine had posted 300 pictures into an album called “Wedding,” and my first thought was, “Oh wow, I didn’t even know she was getting married!” and then when I looked at the pictures I realized it was just a wedding that she attended. (I don’t even think she was in it…just a guest. Which seems extreme to me.)
But at least those people are all over 18. Lately, I can’t stop worrying about the whole phenomenon of posting a million pictures of your baby on your Facebook page. Let me just admit, I don’t think I will be able to resist that, for a couple reasons.
1) How can you not show off something like that? How cute would an Instagramed baby be? Am I right?
2) I’m pretty sure that I’m still like halfway in the closet with this whole “being pregnant” thing, and if I post a couple pictures of me and Drew holding an infant, it’s going to make it a lot clearer.
(There’s also a whole other side issue of the “attention wanted” posts, versus the “for entertainment purposes” posts, versus the “for the family members” posts.)
It’s not just the possibility that one day this kid will want to be the president (ha, yeah right), and won’t want pictures of himself or herself naked in a bathtub. It’s also a safety thing. Drew pointed out there are people on Facebook, who we don’t really know in real life…but we know EVERYTHING about their (very young) children. Like, we could probably use the knowledge we have, to kidnap said children. And we would never do that, because we’re cool, but there are people out there who would totally do that.
I can’t claim to be particularly good at staying anonymous – I’m sure that I’ve accidentally let slip too many details here. Things that I didn’t mean to say, but “oops” happens.
And even if I can resist putting a bunch of pictures – there are still all these other people running around with cameras and phones and wanting to post stuff.
I can be kind of private about some things. And delivery is going to be one of those things. I’m good having our parents in and out during labor, and hanging out…but when it comes down to business, it’s really important to me that it’s me and Drew (and I guess some doctors or something). It fits with our whole “we’re a team” thing.
So I’m going to be pretty bummed if I come home two days later and find out that it’s already on Facebook, because someone jumped the gun – purely out of excitement, I’m sure. But how do you put that out there, without sounding like a total bitch? It’s just gotten too hard to put restrictions on things like that.
Friend anecdotes: one friend was very strict about things early on. She didn’t want her kid posted anywhere linked with his name, or with the names of her or her husband. I think she was thinking about safety. But eventually she’s posted more and more pictures and videos of him on her Facebook, which I’m sure has the highest security settings.
Another friend has been strict the whole time, and her kid is 3 years old. She’s also told family members to take things down because she doesn’t want them just floating out there. She also told us a story about a relative posting a video online with the caption, “[Name]’s first steps!!” And all the family members were commenting and loving it, and she had to say, “Hey, listen, she had her first steps a week ago and her father and I were there you can’t just take that away from us.”
I guess that’s my fear. My long-winded fear. I just don’t want this to get away from us. I want the two of us – Drew and me – to be the keepers of the milestones and the reveals. That’s all. I guess. Luckily, none of our parents are really into Facebook, so they won’t go crazy. Other friends and relatives…might be harder to rein in.
Silver lining, which I keep reminding myself: I am so grateful that this kid is arriving into a world of people excited and happy to meet him or her.
PS. He or she has been kicking the whole time I’ve been writing this – perhaps as if to say, “Moooo-oom, you’re embarrassing me” ?
5 replies on “Oh brave new world: Babies on the internet”
Um, first of all – CONGRATS! I didn’t know you were expecting! Second of all, it was SO great to see your smiling face last week! Third of all, you CAN restrict what goes out there by not doing everything in the digital world. My goddaughter, who is six, has no digital profile or images online whatsoever – her parents send me actual photographs, and if we do email pics, it is in private. At least what we think is private. I think your concerns for your child’s safety and security are very well founded, and, erring on the side of safety as opposed to popularity with friends and family is your job as a parent. And I personally think you will be an amazing parent!
That being said – email those pic when the little angel arrives! I promise not to share on FB or anywhere else!
Thanks! Like I said, I don’t have a good way of bringing it up out of the blue. =)
I don’t expect that we’ll stay totally off of Facebook/the internet…but you know, I’m just trying to figure out a balance between “too overprotective” and “telling everyone the kid’s address and a list of their fears.” AND, God forbid, I just saw an article today about a woman who was attacked while she was trying to do a solo row around the perimeter of Lake Michigan – and the guy knew exactly where to find her because of details on her blog. So I guess…this here is actually the danger zone, and not Facebook.
With FB you can really limit who sees what by controlling your friends or grouping them (I just removed ALL albums of Scott from my FB except for family- I didn’t even know you could do that!). As for what other people post… that’s harder. Every pic that I am posted in, but is not mine, any friend can see… I have to figure that one out.
Yeah, I guess with FB photos it’s less about safety (since I hopefully know and mostly trust everyone I’m friends with) – and it’s more about wanting to control what goes out there. Control freak much? I guess I’ll have to let go at some point…
You can control what photos of you appear when other people post them too. I mean… you can’t make them disappear, but you can make sure they aren’t associated with your name/identity.
I have it set to approve everything I’m tagged in, so I get a little notice before it will appear on my timeline – this includes posts & photos, but not actually writing on the timeline. This means anyone who I want to control info to about myself will mostly see only what I want to see. Of course, if I’m mutually friends with someone else, then I can’t control it.
But… I think that the next generation of kids, who are even more digital natives, it won’t be the end of the world. They will understand how to control data, and they will also not be as afraid of it.
Lastly, as a friend who is over- ambitious with a camera, I think what is important is communication. If people are your friends, they will understand what you want, but I think having a person to person conversation is important. Scottysmom and I have talked about it before, and I have tried to be respectful of what I post, with regards to what she has said.
But, I will make a point of difference between a wedding and a baby. The baby and the baby’s milestones do belong to you and your family.
I think a wedding is different. I think that is a special occasion that has circles of importance at it – there is the couple, the family, the bridal party, but then there are a lot of different types of friends. And a friend’s wedding can be an important part of that month or year in your life, even if it is not your own. You can have a wonderful experience at a wedding, and only talk to the bride & groom for five minutes. Even working a wedding, you can really admire a cake, a flower arrangement, a crazy dress. And social media is about sharing what is fun and what your like in your life.
And this comment is now longer than some of my blog posts….